Touring the Battle of Cool Spring

Gen. Jubal A. Early
(From Battles & Leaders)

“We haven’t taken Washington, but we’ve scared Abe Lincoln like hell.”Confederate general Jubal A. Early

After marching to within sight of the Capitol dome in Washington, D.C. on July 11, 1864, the capital of the United States seemed within Confederate general Jubal Early’s grasp. However, with the imposing Fort Stevens in his front and news that additional Union reinforcements were on the way to protect the capital, Early decided to withdraw on the night of July 12 and return to Virginia. Four days after Early withdrew he crossed the Blue Ridge Mountains at Snickers Gap and entered the Shenandoah Valley. While Early’s troops hoped to rest, a Union pursuit force commanded by Gen. Horatio G. Wright followed. On July 17 Union cavalry commanded by Gen. Alfred Duffie tried to drive Early’s pickets posted on the Shenandoah River’s western shore at Castleman’s Ferry (the place where the Berryville Turnpike crosses the Shenandoah River) but to no avail. Efforts by Union cavalry the following morning to drive Early’s pickets from Castleman’s Ferry proved equally futile. With a frontal assault no longer feasible Union generals Wright and George Crook agreed to flank the Confederate position by crossing the Shenandoah River approximately two miles downstream.

From the kiosk proceed back to the paved trail (located to your right if you are facing the kiosk), follow for .03 miles and turn left positioning yourself so that you are looking at the majestic white home “The Retreat” and have a view of the road which passes to the left of the house.

Gen. Horatio G. Wright (From J. Noyalas, private collection)

“Send a force across the river and develop the enemy.”

General Horatio G. Wright’s order to General George Crook

During the time of the battle the home in front of you (currently a private residence so please do not trespass) was owned by Judge Richard Parker, best known for presiding over John Brown’s trial in 1859. Around 2 p.m. on July 18 Gen. Crook ordered Col. Joseph Thoburn to take his small division and Col. Daniel Frost’s brigade, approximately 5,000 men, to cross the Shenandoah River at Island Ford. John Carrigan, a local tailor in his mid-forties who served as a musician earlier in the conflict in the 2nd Virginia Infantry (CSA), helped Thoburn navigate narrow paths through the mountain to your front. Shortly before 3:00 p.m. Thoburn’s troops marched down Parker’s Ford Road which you can Gen. Jubal A. Early (Battles & Leaders) Gen. Horatio G. Wright (J. Noyalas, private collection) see situated to the left of Judge Parker’s Retreat. The original Parker’s Ford Road traversed the ground behind you and carried Thoburn’s troops to Island Ford.

From “The Retreat” continue on the path (with “The Retreat” on your right side) and proceed on the paved path, around the pond, turn left onto mowed trail and proceed to interpretive marker to your front near the Shenandoah River. The distance from your second stop to the third one is .10 miles.

Learn More about John Carrigan

Born in New York City circa 1818 John Carrigan worked as a tailor near Castleman’s Ferry in the decades prior to the Civil War. On April 18, 1861, Carrigan, affectionately known as “Barney” by his friends, enlisted as a musician in the 2^nd Virginia Infantry CSA. Carrigan deserted on March 11, 1862. While nothing indicates what compelled Carrigan to desert he ventured to Maryland and in January 1864 enlisted in a Union regiment, 3^rd Maryland Potomac Home Brigade. He served as the regiment’s chief musician until he mustered out of service on May 29, 1865. As a member of the 3^rd Maryland, Carrigan was part of Gen. Wright’s pursuit force. After the conflict Carrigan returned to Clarke County and settled near Boyce. On June 16, 1888, Carrigan committed suicide.

Col. George Wells
(From J. Noyalas, private collection)

“We crossed where the water was about breast-deep, and the bottom very slippery. After crossing we…. went to work throwing up light breastworks.”

Private Benjamin S. Bogardus, 170th Ohio Infantry

Around 3:30 p.m. on July 18 Col. George Wells’ brigade led Thoburn’s advance to and across Island Ford. You can see the southern edge of Island Ford to your front. As Wells’ men crossed here at Island Ford Confederate pickets from Maj. Jesse Richardson’s 42nd Virginia Infantry attempted to block Wells’ advance but failed. Wells’ troops captured sixteen of Richardson’s command during the crossing. As Thoburn’s troops crossed the Shenandoah River Col. Thoburn questioned the Confederate prisoners who informed him “that the divisions of the rebel Generals Gordon and Rodes were within a mile or two of the ford, and that General Early was present.” Fearful that his small command would be separated from the remainder of the Union army Thoburn appealed to his superior Gen. Crook “for further instructions.” Crook promptly ordered Thoburn to not continue with his efforts to flank the Confederate position near Castleman’s Ferry, but instead “to take as strong a position as possible… and await the arrival of a division of the Sixth Corps.”

From this stop proceed closer to the Shenandoah River, keeping in mind personal safety at all times. The distance from your third stop to the fourth is .04 miles

Exploring the Environment’s Impact

Throughout the Civil War threats to a soldier’s life came not only from enemy troops, but the natural environment. Excessive heat, bone-chilling cold, precipitation, and natural features such as rivers sometimes proved as deadly as bullets and shells. As Thoburn’s regiments crossed the Shenandoah on the afternoon of July 18 Private John Gundy, 170^th Ohio, “ran against a snag in the river.” In Gundy’s attempt to free his left leg from whatever snagged him in the “waist deep” water he ruptured his groin. Infection soon followed and prompted his discharge from the regiment on September 10, 1864. Gundy never recovered. He died on October 30, 1864.

Col. Joseph Thoburn (From N. Picerno, private collection)

“I posted my command in two lines… the Second Brigade commanded by myself, on the right, the First Brigade, commanded by Colonel Wells, on the left, and the Third Brigade, commanded by Colonel Frost, in the center.”

Col. Joseph Thoburn.

Although trees on the opposite shore currently obscure the positions held by Thoburn’s troops, there are sometimes views of the ground on the river’s opposite shore through the trees to your left front. Col. Thoburn deployed his men in two main lines. After deploying skirmishers on an upland ridge just east of the Cool Spring house, Thoburn established his main line about seventyfive yards from the river’s western bank. Thoburn established a reserve line “in an old road on the riverbanks behind a low stone fence,” a position Thoburn believed “afforded excellent protection” for his command. Around 5:00 p.m. Gen’s. Wright and Crook, from their perch atop the Blue Ridge, spied Confederate divisions advancing on Thoburn’s position. Crook implored Wright to withdraw Thoburn’s division back to this side of the Shenandoah River, but Wright refused. Instead Wright told Crook that he intended to send Gen. James Ricketts’ division across the river to support Thoburn.

From this stop return to the paved path. Walk along the paved path keeping the Shenandoah River on your left. As you walk on the path you will pass an interpretive marker on your right. Take a moment to read the interpretive marker and then continue on the path until you see a small bench on a rise to your left. The bench marks your next stop, Parker’s Hole. The distance from your fourth stop to the fifth is .78 miles.

Gen. Robert E. Rodes (From the Library of Congress)

“The line of battle… was breaking in great disorder and retreating across the river… Col. Young was on the bank of the river trying to rally the men.”

C.E. McKoy, 1st Maine Cavalry

As Confederate forces launched their attack Thoburn and his commanders thought Early’s regiments would launch a frontal assault. None anticipated that Thoburn’s right flank would be the focus of the Confederate attack. The Union right flank was located opposite of where you are now standing on the river’s western bank. When Confederates from Gen. Robert Rodes’ division charged toward Thoburn’s right flank its defenders—a hodge-podge of dismounted cavalry commanded by Col. Samuel K. Young—did not put up much resistance. Many troops from Young’s command broke and retreated across the river. While many of Young’s men made it safely across to the area where you are now located, some drowned in “Parker’s Hole” (located to your front)—a deep abyss amid the river’s otherwise fordable waters in July 1864. Parker’s Hole is located to your front. With the retreat of the majority of Young’s command to the Shenandoah River’s eastern shore, the task of defending against Rodes’ assault fell upon the shoulders of Col. John L. Vance’s 4th West Virginia Infantry.

Why did Young’s Command Withdraw so Quickly?

While the troops in Young’s command had experienced combat as cavalrymen, none had experienced it as members of a provisional brigade asked to fight as infantry. Assembled thirteen days earlier at Camp Stoneman, a camp for dismounted cavalry located south of Washington, D.C., at Giesboro Point, Young’s command, which consisted of 1,000 troopers from twenty-seven different cavalry regiments never had an opportunity to appropriately prepare for combat as foot soldiers. Unfamiliar with infantry drill and unaccustomed to using muskets one of Young’s dismounted troopers complained: “There were several reasons we could not… fight… those who had carbines had to give them up, and we were armed as infantry… besides being mixed together, as we were, without organization, was enough to take the fight out of the best troops in the world.” Not all of Young’s troopers fled the field. Among those who remained was Private William H. Cushman. A railroad conductor from Cleveland, Ohio, Cushman enlisted in the 2^nd Ohio Cavalry on August 24, 1861. After Young’s command broke, Cushman, and a contingent of other troopers, took cover behind a stone wall and attempted to slow the Confederate attack. Cushman was killed when a Confederate bullet struck him in the head. Initially buried by his comrades on the western bank of the Shenandoah River, Cushman’s remains were moved to the Winchester National Cemetery after the conflict. He is buried in grave 792.

From Parker’s Hole return to the paved path and continue on the trail keeping the Shenandoah River on your left side. Once the trail turns from asphalt to concrete stop and face toward the Shenandoah River. The distance from your fifth stop to the sixth is .17 miles.

Lt. Col. Thomas F. Wildes (From Ohio in the War, 1868)

“Colonel Thoburn… was the coolest man on the field.”

Lt. Col. Thomas Wildes, 116th Ohio

Depending on the time of year and the foliage on the trees you can see some of the upland ridges on the river’s opposite shore. You are now positioned opposite the battlefield’s northernmost point. In an effort to alleviate the pressure now being felt by Col. John Vance’s 4th West Virginia Infantry—a regiment which had a portion of its members carrying discharge papers in their pockets—Thoburn repositioned his regiments to counter Rodes’ attack. In addition to moving the 116th Ohio to his beleaguered northern flank, Thoburn also ordered Col. Daniel Frost to wheel his brigade so that instead of facing west it faced north and presented a front to Rodes’ division. In the process of maneuvering his brigade Col. Frost was mortally wounded, “shot through the bowels.” His wounding and the fire the brigade endured from Gen. Gabriel Wharton’s division caused a panic, compelled his brigade to flee the battlefield and cross the river to the relative safety of the property now owned by Shenandoah University. While portions of Thoburn’s command fled to this side of the river some believed it best to remain and fight until nightfall. From their position near the river’s edge—a road bounded on its western edge by a stone wall—Thoburn’s troops fended off additional Confederate assaults.

Reverse direction on the trail so that the Shenandoah River is on your right side. As you proceed you will notice a concrete trail moving up the slopes to your left. Cross the small strip of grass and take the concrete path up the slope. Follow the concrete path until you reach the wayside marker near the crest. Please note that this is a somewhat steep incline. The distance from your sixth stop to the seventh is .15 miles.

Col. Charles H. Tompkins (From MOLLUS, US Army War College)

“Col. Tompkins… opened twenty guns upon them [the Confederates] and somewhat demoralized them… [the] batteries did some of the best shooting ever seen in modern warfare.”

Correspondent for New York Herald attached to Gen. Wright’s command

As elements of Thoburn’s command fended off multiple Confederate attacks Col. Charles H. Tompkins, Wright’s artillery chief, deployed twenty cannons to support Thoburn’s regiments. On the bluffs above you and to your right, if you are facing the bluffs, Lt. Jacob H. Lamb’s Battery C, 1st Rhode Island Light Artillery took position and fired across the river. Two other batteries took position on the heights to your south—Battery G, 1st Rhode Island Light Artillery and Battery E, 1st West Virginia Artillery. While the Union gunners helped slow the Confederate offensive that evening, some shells fired from the heights in front of you—due to the closeness of Union and Confederate lines—occasionally landed among Thoburn’s command causing additional casualties.

Proceed down the concrete path and return to the original asphalt path. Please note that there are a variety of paths in this area so make certain that you are on the original path, the one closest to the river. Continue along the asphalt path (keeping the river on your right) to the area between Parker’s Island and Island Ford. The distance from your seventh stop to the eighth is .41 miles.

“General Ricketts… did not think it prudent under the circumstances to cross his men.”

Gen. George Crook

General George Crook (From the Library of Congress)

As you stand on the path with the Shenandoah River to your right, the area to your front was filled with troops from Gen. James Ricketts’ division. Ricketts’ regiments arrived in the area to your front around 6:00 p.m. As Ricketts’ regiments readied themselves to cross and Thoburn continued to shift troops to his right flank Gen. Crook conferred with Gen. Ricketts’ about the best place to cross. After seeing the great strength of the Confederate assault Ricketts refused to move his men across and support Thoburn. Angered, Crook then sought Gen. Wright’s intercession, but Wright supported Ricketts in his decision. Wright believed nothing would be gained by sending Ricketts’ division across the Shenandoah River. Troops in Thoburn’s command disagreed and believed that support from Ricketts’ regiments could have turned the battle’s tide in favor of Union victory. Once all of Thoburn’s troops crossed back to this side of the river after nightfall they encountered men from Ricketts’ division who told them that they wanted to cross the river and support them, but Gen. Wright and Gen. Ricketts would not allow it. Many of Thoburn’s veterans never forgave Ricketts and Wright.

5th NYHA Flags (From J. Noyalas, private collection)

Among the units engaged at the Battle of Cool Spring were elements of the 5th New York Heavy Artillery. In the war’s aftermath veterans from the regiment sold photographs like the one you see above to raise money for the 5th New York Heavy Artillery Veteran Association. The unit’s national colors proudly displayed its battle honors. Note on the far left side of the fifth stripe from the bottom the battle honor “Snikers Gap VA, July 18th 64.” Union regiments oftentimes referred to the Battle of Cool Spring as the Battle of Snickers Gap.

Continue on the path keeping the Shenandoah River on your right side and proceed to where you can view the mid-point of the island. The distance from your eighth stop to the ninth is 0.21 miles.

“On picket during the day. The boys tried their Spencer rifles. Several Rebs shot.”

Capt. Mason Whiting Tyler (From Tyler’s Recollections, 1912)

Capt. Mason Whiting Tyler, 37th Massachusetts Infantry

As Thoburn’s men “lighted” fires “on the river bank” and prepared “coffee the soldier’s elixir of life” a contingent of soldiers from the 37^th Massachusetts Infantry and 2^nd Rhode Island Infantry, commanded by Lieutenant Colonel George Montague, who served as officer of the day, picketed the river’s eastern bank. The pickets, armed with seven-shot Spencer rifles, could hear the groans and cries of wounded soldiers stranded on one of the islands in the river’s center or on its western shore. Throughout the night and into the following morning Montague’s pickets aided wounded Union soldiers escape to the eastern side of the Shenandoah.

This concludes your tour. Thank you for visiting Shenandoah University’s Shenandoah River Campus at Cool Spring Battlefield. You can follow the paved path back to the kiosk where you began the tour.